Case Packer vs Tray Packer: What’s the Difference?

Learn the essential difference between case and tray packers and when their format works best for your application.

Updated: June 30, 2026
Case and tray packed with aluminum cans on a gray background

Introduction

Case packer vs tray packer – what’s the difference? If you’re evaluating secondary packaging equipment for the first time, or are trying to get your specs straight before a conversation with an OEM, this is a question that comes up occasionally. And it’s a fair one. The terminology gets used loosely and sometimes interchangeably, which only adds confusion.

Here’s a clean, no-jargon answer.

The Short Version

A case packer places your products into a fully enclosed corrugated box with six sides, sealed shut. A tray packer places them into an open-top container — typically a corrugated tray or pad — that leaves the product visible and accessible from above.

When Do You Use a Case Packer?

Cases are the right choice when:

  • Your product needs protection from handling, stacking, or environmental exposure
during shipping and storage
  • Retail shelving requires a fully enclosed display or shipper carton
  • Your distribution chain involves significant conveyor and palletizer handling where
product would otherwise be exposed
  • You’re running products with irregular shapes or higher fragility that benefit from
containment

Think canned goods, glass bottles, pouches, or anything that ships long distances through a multi-step distribution network.

When Do You Use a Tray Packer?

Trays make sense when:

  • The product is inherently stable and doesn’t require a lid for protection
  • Retail display or club store formats call for open-top visibility
  • Shrink film is applied over the tray to create a bundle (the film provides the structural integrity)
  • Your product benefits from a low-profile, open package that’s easy to stock directly
from the case

Think beverage multipacks, canned beverages in club packs, or produce items heading to a retailer who shelf-stocks straight from the tray.

What About Tray/Shrink Combinations?

Many lines run a tray packer paired with a shrink wrap tunnel, creating a shrink-wrapped tray. The tray provides a base and structure while the film holds everything together and adds tamper resistance. This is a very common format in beverages, dairy, and snacks.

Pro Tip

If your application is a shrink-wrapped bundle without a tray base, that’s a pure shrink wrapper — no tray involved.

Does Douglas Make Both?

Yes. Douglas offers both case packers and tray packers across multiple product families. They are engineered for CPG applications throughout beverage, dairy, snacks, personal care, household goods, frozen or prepared foods, and more. The right choice depends on your product, your packaging format, your line speed, and where the package goes after it leaves your facility.

Not sure which direction makes sense for your application? That’s exactly the kind of question our team is equipped to work through with you.

Looking for a case or tray packer?

Give us a call. Douglas product specialists can answer questions and help you discover which solution is the best fit for your application.

About This Article's Domain Specialist

Andy Q. has worked at Douglas for 9 years and currently holds the position of VP, Marketing & Business Development.

Read full bio »

Related Articles

See All Articles
Predictive vs Preventive Maintenance article header graphic - PF Curve

Secondary Packaging 101

Predictive vs Preventive Maintenance: How Do They Differ?

Learn how to tell which type of maintenance your high-value assets need and where traditional maintenance still makes business sense.

Read more »

Operator running a packaging machine's HMI with a title overlay stating "Machine Efficiency ≠ OEE"

Secondary Packaging 101

A Commonly Misunderstood Metric – What Is Machine Efficiency?

Machine efficiency is one way of understanding how much capacity you’re using. Learn what machine efficiency is, how to calculate it, and how you can leverage it for growth.

Read more »

Plastic bottles on conveyor at fast speed

Secondary Packaging 101

What Does Line Speed Mean? And Why Is It So Often Misquoted?

Understand important speed metrics and learn which questions will tell you the most about machine performance and productivity.

Read more »